I’m Not Racist But…….
We have seen in Ireland over the past year or two, increasing hostility towards those seeking refuge, especially in towns where proposals for housing asylum seeker accommodation are made. This has happened in my home town of Newtownmountkennedy recently. Emotions are running high and I’ve been sucked into various online discussions….and here are my thoughts on certain aspects of this situation.
Ireland has experienced a surge of incomers, with over 100,000 Ukrainians now living here, unprecedented numbers of those seeking international protection and all in the midst of a housing crisis. It is not surprising that tensions have arisen but what is worrying, is that so many are reacting with tired old racist tropes, while at the same time using the ‘I’m not racist’ by-line. Recently I was told online that most Muslims (that’s 25% of the world’s population) are criminals and local social media platforms for my town are full of people saying they are ‘not racist’ but they don’t want asylum seekers because they will ‘increase crime’, and make the town ‘unsafe for women and children’. This ridiculous stereotype that black men are more of a danger to European women than indigenous sexual offenders goes back at least to when Shakespeare wrote Othello in 1604!
The thing is, when we negatively generalise/stereotype/prejudge any group based on nationality/ethnic group, that is racist – strange though this clearly is to many! You can’t say migrants bring more crime and not be racist unless…….you have studied all crime amongst all migrant and non-migrant groups over time allowing for a million different controls, including PTSD, health care, structural racism, etc. etc. and no credible study would conclude that it is a person’s immigration status/ethnicity which determined criminality. Gardai in Ireland don’t even record the ethnicity of perpetrators of crime but when questioned they’ve also corrected certain deliberate online rumours that ‘foreigners’ were suspects in assault cases (when the Gardai were looking for Irish men).
Nor can any vetting system determine who is ‘safe’ and who isn’t, as not all previous crime is documented in any country of origin (many don’t have this level of infrastructure) and not all future crime is predictable – people can be more or less liable to commit crimes based on the duress they are under at any given time.
Asylum seekers disposing of their passports in the airport may mean someone might want to hide a criminal background or more likely, they’ve heard a rumour that having no passport will delay their asylum case and give them more time in Ireland. Given that we live in a world where human rights abuses and conflict are rife in so many countries, isn’t it more likely that a sizeable portion of those claiming asylum are actually feeling unsafe rather than being criminals on the run?
Accepting migrants or even tourists means some will be dodgy, but outcomes are always better when people are cared for. Overcrowded hotels aren’t conducive to calm, regardless of ethnicity. And the fact that there is upheaval and unrest in a country of origin doesn’t mean a people is by nature violent like many people at anti-immigrant protests are claiming, it just means the countries are probably going through something like what Ireland went through with the Rising, War of Independence, Civil War and the Troubles. That is the reality of post-colonialism and ongoing neo-colonialism. But that doesn’t mean no migrants commit crimes. Of course, they do. But when crimes are committed by non-whites, they are seen as proof of a racist theory and get disproportionate attention, fuelled of course, by racism.
Here’s one definition of racism: “prejudice, discrimination, or antagonism by an individual, community, or institution against a person or people on the basis of their membership of a particular racial or ethnic group, typically one that is a minority or marginalized” and the Irish Network Against Racism understands racism as any action, practice, policy, law, speech, or incident which has the effect (whether intentional or not) of undermining anyone’s enjoyment of their human rights, based on their actual or perceived ethnic or national origin or background, where that background is that of a marginalised or historically subordinated group.
It doesn’t matter if a fight broke out in a direct provision centre in the past, we still can’t judge a group of strangers from multiple continents on the actions of a different group of strangers from multiple continents, as is happening where I live in Newtownmounkennedy. Nor can we say drunken Irish lads on holidays in Spain or charitable Irish aid workers in Africa represent who we Irish are as a nation. Each person represents themselves, not their nation or ‘race’.
Using terms such as ‘flooded’ or ‘invaded’ when referring to people is dehumanising. This is the kind of language we use for war/natural disaster/insects etc., not the kind of language we can use and then argue that we just want an open discussion on immigration without being labelled as racist.
Can the immigration issue be discussed without resorting to racist tropes? Can we legitimately critique the government’s handling of migration without resorting to stereotyping? Yes, they have made a mess of it by and large so of course we should be able to discuss this but first we need to:
1. Acknowledge our privilege as a peaceful privileged European nation, one of the richest in the world and one which is (per capita) disproportionately ravaging the natural resources and basis of life of many of the countries producing these asylum seekers. Yes we have our problems, and not everyone’s needs are met by any stretch, but in terms of peace, democracy and prosperity we are in the top 10 on most lists.
2. Acknowledge the millions of Irish, amongst them honest workers, drunken scammers and everything in between who emigrated legally and illegally, often to countries where we contributed to eliminating the native populations to take their land and resources.
3. Acknowledge how our health and service industries are being kept afloat by non-Irish, and we still lack workers in many trades and need immigration if the economy is to keep functioning.
4. Remember that the European values that many want to ‘defend’ are supposed to be Christian ones and that means tolerance, sharing, empathy, compassion and generosity.
5. Take into account the obscene levels of wealth captured by a small minority in the world and growing wealth inequality in Ireland, and how this contributes to a feeling of scarcity and lack among so many in one of the richest, resource-devouring countries in the world. And how the housing crisis is due to free market economics, not migration.
6. Acknowledge the growing conflict, climate chaos and poverty in the world. Immigration to Ireland is going to increase over the next few decades as parts of the world become uninhabitable. And no, we are not ‘full’, we have a low population density but an increasingly dense population, in that social media has dumbed people down and destroyed critical thinking.
And no, we are not ‘full’, we have a low population density but an increasingly dense population, in that social media has dumbed people down and destroyed critical thinking.
In Ireland, we need to meet everyone’s fundamental needs for housing, health, education and so forth without getting confused by ethnicity, and we need to stop equating a high level of disposable income/consumerism with a good quality of life.
The people of Ireland can respond to growing immigration with fear and bigotry or react with curiosity and compassion. Diversity (and biodiversity) bring myriad benefits.
Let’s step up to the challenges of the 21st century without the entitlement we developed in the 20th one.



Leave a Reply