Fast Fashion in Ireland: Why the Debate Is Missing a Crucial Dimension

Image via Freestocks on Unsplash
Over the past few months, there has been significant media coverage around the environmental impact of fast fashion in Ireland. Ireland is now leading in the EU in per capita textile consumption and produces double the EU average of textile waste. We are now dumping half a tonne of clothing in landfills every minute. This is an appalling level of waste, impacting emissions, soils, ecosystems and pollution levels.
But the media coverage and general analysis of this issue, as with much of the overall sustainability discourse, misses important considerations regarding the inner cultural and psychological drivers.
Frequently, the debate focuses on ethics & sustainability vs affordability & livelihoods. Advocates of free-market solutions often point to more voluntary and incremental solutions, such as consumer education and corporate responsibility, arguing that low-cost fashion serves economic growth and small retailers. Social justice-based concerns focus on the inability of lower-income consumers to afford sustainable clothing, while sustainability advocates argue for more industry regulation as well as consumer behaviour change.
These arguments often conflate fast fashion with clothing and miss important aspects of the issue. Clothing is about the human need to protect and cover the body, whereas fashion is associated with a need for belonging and self-esteem. In Ireland, our problem is with fast fashion, not clothing. No one is at risk of walking around naked, and though some of the more marginalised members of our society do lack essential clothing items, this is a separate issue from that of mass textile waste.
Much of the clothing which is discarded in Ireland is in perfect condition, but in its short lifespan, it has become undesirable. The central issues are a need to keep up with peers, a cultural emphasis on newness and appearance and a focus on aspirational lifestyles. There is also an issue with manufactured desire through strong social media influence and advertising.
There is enough clothing on this planet to serve the global population for the next six generations, yet we in Ireland include the ability to afford ‘new and not second-hand clothes’ as one of the 11 basic deprivation indicators. This recognises that to participate in our society and to insulate against a perceived sense of social unworthiness or a lack of dignity, many of us feel the need to wear new or on-trend clothing. This perceived need compels us to contribute to a grossly unethical and unsustainable industry. Our sense of being ‘good enough’ ironically relies on the exploitation of workers in the Global South and the degradation of the Earth systems on which we all depend.
We need to examine the cultural and psychological factors that explain why people in Ireland are consuming and discarding more fast fashion than elsewhere. We know that the fast fashion issue is particularly associated with urban youth buying clothes multiple times a month. We also know that young people are generally not experiencing good mental health in Ireland. More than a quarter of the adolescents described their mental health as “bad” or “very bad” in 2024, more than a third reported self-harming in their lifetime, and one in ten reported attempting suicide in their lifetime. Relatedly, perhaps, Ireland’s daily time spent on social media often exceeds averages in developed nations.
Fashion is about belonging, and Ireland ranks highest in Europe for loneliness, with those aged 16-24 and 18-34 reporting the highest levels. Research shows that those with insecure or poor relational attachment are, on average, more vulnerable to consumerist impulses because consumption can act as a temporary substitute for unmet emotional and relational needs. Overconsumption is as much to do with the crisis of loneliness and poor mental health in our society as it is about supply and demand.
To address Ireland’s fast fashion crisis, we need more than regulation and consumer education. We need to understand the cultural, emotional and psychological forces driving overconsumption — especially among young people — and integrate these insights into policy, advocacy and public dialogue.
“People don’t need enormous cars; they need admiration and respect. They don’t need a constant stream of new clothes; they need to feel that others consider them to be attractive, and they need excitement and variety and beauty. People don’t need electronic entertainment; they need something interesting to occupy their minds and emotions. And so forth. Trying to fill real but nonmaterial needs-for identity, community, self-esteem, challenge, love, joy-with material things is to set up an unquenchable appetite for false solutions to never-satisfied longings. A society that allows itself to admit and articulate its nonmaterial human needs, and to find nonmaterial ways to satisfy them, world require much lower material and energy throughputs and would provide much higher levels of human fulfillment.” ― Donella Meadows



Leave a Reply