Can we have sustainability without social trust?
For citizens to engage with sustainability issues and support much-needed change at a policy level, social and institutional trust are essential. This includes citizen-to-citizen relationships (social trust) to foster participation and environmental behaviours, as well as citizen-to-government relationships (institutional trust) for policy support.
Social trust aids environmental action
Social trust is basically a belief in other people, a perception that people are generally honest and reliable. Unsurprisingly, people are more likely to act on behalf of the environment if they believe that others will also do so. Conversely, if people fear that others are ‘free-riding’ or using up more than their fair share of the Earth’s resources, they are less likely to make sacrifices on behalf of the collective. Social trust, then, gives people a sense of self-efficacy; it makes individuals feel that it is worthwhile to act. Worryingly, a recent global study revealed that while 86% of respondents worldwide endorse pro-climate social norms, most systematically underestimate the willingness of their fellow citizens to act, leading to reduced or conditional pro-environmental behaviour. This is known as the perception gap. People care more than we think, and it is important to reinforce this message to counteract the resurgence in climate denialism and scepticism.
In terms of collective action, social trust and capital are also crucial. As anyone who has tried to organise at a community or collective level will know, higher levels of social capital (a combination of social networks, norms, and social trust) are associated with collective action. For change to happen, organisers need to cooperate and trust one another and have networks in place to spread ideas and build movements.
Inequality and the breakdown of social trust
Social trust is based on many factors, one of which is inequality. Income inequality also harms subjective well-being levels in society. Reduced well-being and social trust both make pro-environmental action less likely.
The 2025 UN World Social Report highlighted declining social trust, social fragmentation and destabilisation of societies globally. It linked this to widespread economic precarity, enormous inequality and the spread of misinformation and disinformation and pointed out that over 50% of the global population has little or no trust in their government.
For the state to implement mitigation and adaptation measures, institutional trust is needed.
high but declining Trust in Ireland
Ireland is lucky as it enjoys one of the highest levels of social trust in a 2023 OECD survey, with 83% of respondents in Ireland reporting high or moderately high trust. However, only one in four people (26%) trust political parties, while just 47% trust the national government (Social Justice Ireland, 2024). As elsewhere, there is a trend towards increasing distrust of business, government, media and NGOs, with some attributing this to instability due to the aftermath of the COVID pandemic, the cost-of-living and housing crises, or the result of online disinformation.
Rise of the Far-Right
As is the case elsewhere in Europe and globally, far-right online influence has grown rapidly in Ireland, primarily spreading hate for minorities but also spreading climate scepticism. Though electorally limited, these groups actively foster distrust in the State, spread hate and seek to reshape cultural norms. Online activity and local agitation are contributing to growing social violence and the breakdown of social trust and affecting communities all over Ireland. One example is that of Newtownmountkennedy, where I set up a solidarity group called Newtown Together in response to the hate directed at asylum seekers living in the town for 8 months in 2024. Although it is a year since the men were moved from the town, the divisions and hurt remain, after a campaign of intimidation and harassment was unleashed against the asylum seekers and those of us who tried to support them. As is the case globally, the far-right exploitation of inequality to foster hate and distrust in Ireland represents a growing threat, potentially affecting wellbeing, social cohesion and progress on sustainability goals in Ireland.
The need for a Wellbeing Economy
The scale of the challenges is enormous, complex and interconnected. None of us has the solutions. What we do know, however, is that people do better when they feel safe, looked after and have a sense of belonging. If this is in place, there is a stronger likelihood that they will hold self-transcendent, prosocial, altruistic or biospheric values and act accordingly. The struggles of environmentalism and social justice are deeply intertwined, as are those of racial justice, intergenerational trauma and mental health. It would be wise for policy makers to consider that engagement with climate and environmental issues could be fostered not only by giving climate action grants to local organisations etc. but by embracing the principles of a wellbeing economy and moving away from a society where overt consumption, despite the damage it does to the planet and social cohesion, is considered to be the cornerstone of a successful economy.
This blog post is based on some of my research for a Master’s Thesis, ‘Sustainability from the Inside Out’ which can be read here.



Leave a Reply